MIDWESTERN MARX INSTITUTE
  • Home
  • Online Articles
    • Articles >
      • All
      • News
      • Politics
      • Theory
      • Book Reviews
      • Chinese Philosophy Dialogues
    • American Socialism Travels
    • Youth League
  • Dr. Riggins' Book Series
    • Eurocommunism and the State
    • Debunking Russiagate
    • The Weather Makers
    • Essays on Bertrand Russell and Marxism
    • The Truth Behind Polls
    • Piketty's Capital in the 21st Century
    • Lenin's Materialism & Empirio-Criticism
    • Mao's Life
    • Lenin's State and Rev
    • Lenin's LWC Series
    • Anti-Dühring Series
  • Store
    • Books
    • Merchandise
  • YouTube
  • Journal of American Socialist Studies (JASS)
  • Contact
    • Article Submissions
    • The Marks of Capital
  • Online Library
  • Staff

8/4/2022

"Educational DEI Must Be DIY."By: Kevin McCleish

4 Comments

Read Now
 
Picture
​In the wake of what some scholars have termed the "Great Awokening" during the summer of 2020, it has become increasingly popular for school districts to hire Directors of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DDEIs) to both study and address issues related to systemic inequalities hindering students' academic and social development. While such positions may be created with good intentions, in practice DDEIs serve as little more than six-figure public relations campaigns which, by their very nature, are not designed to facilitate transformative pedagogies or politics. Operating within the same internal logic as the social hierarchies engendering inequality in the first place, managerial DDEIs at best only alleviate symptoms of inequality and at worst obstruct the formation of genuine broad-based coalitions of students, educators, and families capable of altering the punishing policies of the neoliberal state visible in our classrooms. By misdiagnosing the source of inequality as a cultural pathology and directing reform from the ivory tower, DDEIs paradoxically inhibit the building of solidarities needed to effectively oppose a system of schooling serving the prerogatives of the laissez-unfaire market.

Despite progressive-sounding titles, DDEIs cannot possibly elicit the structural changes our students need due to the sheer fact that they are members of management. School administrators ultimately function as agents of stabilization, managing the operation of schools with a top-down hierarchical approach. Since management reserves all hiring rights, including the qualifications for and conditions of continued employment, the process of DDEI selection and evaluation can occur without student, teacher, or community input. From the onset, DDEIs are alienated from the constituencies they are meant to serve, which all but ensures coercive or cosmetic compliance rather than authentic support from teachers. Even if a DDEI with transformative convictions did sneak through the interview process, such a person would conflict with management’s ultimate task of ensuring institutional stability. In all likelihood, disruptive DDEIs will either be screened out or not last long, as highly publicized resignations across the country verify.

As DDEIs settle in and begin conducting racial equity audits, unconscious bias trainings, and performative land recognitions, it becomes apparent that their pedagogy is entirely anti-Freirarian. Paulo Freire argued education can only become an authentic source of liberation when the teacher-student hierarchy is transformed into a process where each participant teaches and learns from one another. Such collaborative pedagogical processes cannot occur within the power dynamics inherent to management-employee relations. Like students in classrooms with coercive grading mechanisms, teachers cannot freely participate in an environment where their opinions could be used against them on an evaluation. Beyond the inauthenticity, the premise that teachers need an outside "broker" to train teachers on how to combat inequality in our schools tacitly suggests we are not capable of talking to, teaching, and assessing specific segments of our student population. Such an approach is antagonistic and counter-solidaristic, precluding participation from teachers who are sympathetic to addressing inequalities, but now concerned that their attempts to help will be packaged incorrectly or viewed as commandeering.

Furthermore, in their role as brokers, DDEIs serve to reify rather than interrogate the material forces engendering educational inequality through a technocratic focus on microaggressions, while shrouding the macroaggressions of a political economy rendering our students disposable. DDEIs focus on microaggressions because their positions are predicated upon on the persistence, rather than the elimination of inequality. If their programs and trainings actually produced transformative change, the utility of DDEIs would dissipate, making their positions redundant. Conveniently, culturally pathological explanations for educational inequality do not lend themselves to easy solutions and instead rely upon a constant awareness, facilitated by training, to mitigate. Unlike class inequality, which can be addressed through policy, cultural change is sold as a (lucrative) never-ending individualistic self-improvement enterprise. If teachers can never rid themselves of inherent biases, logically, they will always need DDEIs.  There is little controversy in antiracism disconnected from redistributive programs, making it safe to sell.

While DDEIs adjust educational policies to accommodate inequality, truly transformative pedagogies should seek to alter the existing material conditions underlying inequality. As Henry Giroux reminds us, the pedagogical is always political. It is teachers, not DDEIs, who are best equipped to undertake grassroots coalition building and political action in their communities. Teachers can be organized through existing vehicles, like unions, to create caucuses/committees dedicated to studying and addressing these issues. Is it enough to remove discipline for tardiness or do we organize to improve our public transit system? Is it enough to remove zeroes from the gradebook or do we need to eliminate standardized testing as a form of class filtration and make higher education affordable? Is it enough to increase the demographic diversity in our literature when the school does not have a librarian? No one knows the problems afflicting students like those closest to them and conversations outside the presence of administration leads to democratic and honest dialogues about the issues at hand and the solutions needed for more meaningful change. Through this process of collaboration, rather than DDEI dictation, teachers build coalitions in democratic and authentic manners.

Concretely, teachers can use the tools of solidarity, like collective bargaining, to increase curricular and assessment autonomy, as well as direct resources spent on the DDEI salary and budget to their union caucuses/committees. With contractual language and resources, teachers could then offer staff-led professional development opportunities or bring in expert disrupters outside official school channels to develop initiatives without the threat of censorship or coercion.

As a political project, teachers can create a political action committee within their union to facilitate community relations and exercise agency in the political realm. Ultimately, school superintendents are responsible to the school board, and it is our tremendous responsibility to ensure our students have elected officials who view school equity from the same lens teachers do.
​
The pedagogical cannot be divorced from the political, and these democratic actions augment teacher agency and cultivate the authenticity needed for a mass movement dedicated to transformative change. When it comes to DEI, it must be a DIY endeavor.

Author

Kevin McCleish is a social science educator and labor organizer from Illinois. His work has appeared in the educational journal Critical Questions in Education and on the shop floor. ​


Archives

August 2022
July 2022
June 2022
May 2022
April 2022
March 2022
February 2022
January 2022
December 2021
November 2021
October 2021
September 2021
August 2021
July 2021
June 2021
May 2021
April 2021
March 2021
February 2021
January 2021
December 2020
November 2020
October 2020
September 2020
August 2020
July 2020

Share

4 Comments
Scott
3/16/2023 03:47:15 pm

Why don't you go teach at a CPS school you live so close I bet they need the help and you can give them some of your inherited white privilege and that way they can build equity... You'd never do that though would you Comrad?

Reply
Scott
3/16/2023 08:29:29 pm

Also, you and your wife own Iphones, wear Nikes, and shop at big box stores, you both are massive hypocrites, and the problem. You both are petulant children that never got told no. That's it. Nobody at Lincoln-way has the problems you are writing about, so go do something somewhere where you claim it's a problem. Otherwise, you are just virtue signaling.

Reply
Kevin
3/22/2023 03:21:34 am

Scott,

Despite not comprehending the article’s argument (or even a cursory read), the thoughtful analysis is appreciated.

The month of March seems to be quite the time for you, historically speaking. Fortunately, there was no public endangerment with these words, unlike previous transgressions.

Thanks for keeping up with my academic and political work, Comrade*.

Reply
Roy
3/22/2023 03:36:19 am

Scott,

Seems to me like you have your head in the sand and can’t refrain from making myopic and ill-informed comments. If you want to be a big boy and play theory - praxis game, we can do that, but I’d wager (you a betting man?) you’re not.

Shaming someone for having an iPhone in a political economic system that necessitates professionals to have access to web is hilarious dilettantism at its finest. It’s akin to me saying the climate problem is a result of you not using avocado straws. I wouldn’t do that because it personalizes a systemic problem. I would, however point to your (presumed) love of the military, the globe’s top polluter, and shake you for that. So the iPhone but just shows that you are a child in your thinking and can’t transcend a simplistic reciprocal argument made by a 9 year old.

As for CPS, all students need good teachers, even those of the ruling class. So to ridicule a teacher who is advocating for SYSTEMIC CHANGE for tackling it at the point of hegemony is foolish. Additionally, the LW population is not entirely rich white kids, so what census are you observing? Do you even know that Palestinians live in your attendance area?

Lastly, you responded to an article that ridiculed liberals and actually finds some common grievances (not solutions obviously because Kevin isn’t a neo fascist) with your right wing sycophant friends. That said, you’re the only one who dropped phrases like “white privilege” and “virtue signaling.” Make up your mind. You on team DiAngelo or team Rufo? You can’t ride two saddles with one ass.

Cheers!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

Details

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020

    Categories

    All
    Aesthetics
    Afghanistan
    Althusser
    American Civil War
    American Socialism
    American Socialism Travels
    Anti Imperialism
    Anti-Imperialism
    Art
    August Willich
    Berlin Wall
    Bolivia
    Book Review
    Brazil
    Capitalism
    Censorship
    Chile
    China
    Chinese Philosophy Dialogue
    Christianity
    CIA
    Class
    Climate Change
    COINTELPRO
    Communism
    Confucius
    Cuba
    Debunking Russiagate
    Democracy
    Democrats
    DPRK
    Eco Socialism
    Ecuador
    Egypt
    Elections
    Engels
    Eurocommunism
    Feminism
    Frederick Douglass
    Germany
    Ghandi
    Global Capitalism
    Gramsci
    History
    Hunger
    Immigration
    Imperialism
    Incarceration
    Interview
    Joe Biden
    Labor
    Labour
    Lenin
    Liberalism
    Lincoln
    Linke
    Literature
    Lula Da Silva
    Malcolm X
    Mao
    Marx
    Marxism
    May Day
    Media
    Medicare For All
    Mencius
    Militarism
    MKULTRA
    Mozi
    National Affairs
    Nelson Mandela
    Neoliberalism
    New Left
    News
    Nina Turner
    Novel
    Palestine
    Pandemic
    Paris Commune
    Pentagon
    Peru Libre
    Phillip-bonosky
    Philosophy
    Political-economy
    Politics
    Pol Pot
    Proletarian
    Putin
    Race
    Religion
    Russia
    Settlercolonialism
    Slavery
    Slavoj-zizek
    Slavoj-zizek
    Social-democracy
    Socialism
    South-africa
    Soviet-union
    Summer-2020-protests
    Syria
    Theory
    The-weather-makers
    Trump
    Venezuela
    War-on-drugs
    Whatistobedone...now...likenow-now
    Wilfrid-sellers
    Worker-cooperatives
    Xunzi

All ORIGINAL Midwestern Marx content is under Creative Commons
(CC BY-ND 4.0) which means you can republish our work only if it is attributed properly (link the original publication to the republication) and not modified. 
Proudly powered by Weebly
Photos from U.S. Secretary of Defense, ben.kaden
  • Home
  • Online Articles
    • Articles >
      • All
      • News
      • Politics
      • Theory
      • Book Reviews
      • Chinese Philosophy Dialogues
    • American Socialism Travels
    • Youth League
  • Dr. Riggins' Book Series
    • Eurocommunism and the State
    • Debunking Russiagate
    • The Weather Makers
    • Essays on Bertrand Russell and Marxism
    • The Truth Behind Polls
    • Piketty's Capital in the 21st Century
    • Lenin's Materialism & Empirio-Criticism
    • Mao's Life
    • Lenin's State and Rev
    • Lenin's LWC Series
    • Anti-Dühring Series
  • Store
    • Books
    • Merchandise
  • YouTube
  • Journal of American Socialist Studies (JASS)
  • Contact
    • Article Submissions
    • The Marks of Capital
  • Online Library
  • Staff